ZIP (Zero Interaction Potency)¶
ZIP compares a fitted combination surface, built from per-row and per-column dose–response curves, with the zero-interaction expectation of the two single drugs (Yadav et al. 2015). It is widely used in combination screening, including as the default in SynergyFinder.
Idea¶
- Take each drug's Hill curve from the matrix fit: its potency and slope come from its own single-agent edge (first row or column), with the two plateaus shared by both drugs (see the matrix fitting pipeline on the Bliss independence page).
- Map responses to fraction affected \(f = (\text{effect}_0 - y) / (\text{effect}_0 - \text{effect}_\infty)\). The zero-interaction expectation is Bliss independence on that scale: [ f_{\text{ZIP}} = f_h + f_v - f_h f_v ] (equivalently, the Bliss combination of the two single-drug Hill curves in response units). This is what the Reference view labels “ZIP reference (zero-interaction expectation)”.
- For each row (fixed vertical concentration, varying horizontal drug), fit a three-parameter Hill curve in fraction-affected space: baseline \(f_0\) fixed to the other drug’s single-agent fraction at that row, with free potency, Hill slope, and maximum effect (capped at full effect). For a 5-parameter (asymmetric) drug the slice curve keeps that drug's fitted asymmetry, so a combination with no interaction scores exactly zero. This is a synfit extension: the published method uses symmetric 4-parameter curves, and the two are identical for 4-parameter drugs.
- Do the same for each column (vertical drug vs concentration).
- The fitted combination fraction at cell \((i,j)\) is the average of the row slice and column slice predictions at that cell. The heatmap δ-score compares this fitted surface to \(f_{\text{ZIP}}\), normalised by the response scale.
This is intermediate between purely probabilistic nulls (Bliss, HSA) and strict dose additivity (Loewe): it allows potency and efficacy shifts between drugs without refitting full single-agent curves at every combination.
Delta score¶
where \(y_{\text{ZIP}}\) is the zero-interaction expectation and \(y_{\text{fitted}}\) is the averaged slice-fit combination surface (both in response units). synfit uses the equivalent form \(-(f_{\text{fitted}} - f_{\text{ZIP}})\) in fraction-affected space.
| Delta | Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Negative | Synergy — stronger effect than ZIP predicts |
| Near zero | Additivity in the ZIP sense |
| Positive | Antagonism — weaker effect than ZIP predicts |
For inhibition assays, \(\text{effect}_0\) is the uninhibited response and \(\text{effect}_{\infty}\) the fully inhibited plateau; for activation, the asymptotes are swapped but the same formula and sign convention apply.
Comparison with other models¶
| Property | Bliss | HSA | Loewe CI | ZIP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Null idea | Independent probabilities | Stronger single agent | Dose additivity | Zero interaction in \(f\), then slice-fit combination |
| Uses the fitted single-drug Hill curves? | No (observed edges) | No (observed edges) | Yes | Yes (for the zero-interaction expectation and the slice anchors) |
| Per-row/column extra fits? | No | No | No | Yes (3-parameter slices) |
| Undefined cells? | No | No | Yes (outside single-agent range) | Only where both the row and the column curve fit failed (a warning names the failed rows/columns) |
Further reading¶
- Yadav, B. et al. (2015) "Searching for drug synergy in complex dose-response landscapes" — SynergyFinder and the ZIP score (doi:10.1016/j.csbj.2015.09.001)
- SynergyFinder 2.0 web tool — practical use of ZIP alongside other models
Implementation details
Core (synfit.zip):
zip_reference(...)— Bliss combination of the supplied single-drug Hill parameters in fraction-affected space, mapped back to responses (zero-interaction expectation).zip_fitted_surface(...)— per-row and per-column 3-parameter slice fits in normalised space; fitted combination is the mean of the two slice predictions; maps to response units.zip_delta(...)— \(\delta = -(f_{\text{fitted}} - f_{\text{ZIP}})\) (negative = synergy). Cells where either concentration is zero are NaN. If a slice fit fails, the cell uses the other direction's fit alone; if both fail the cell is NaN (unscored).zip_scores(...)returns all of this plusfailed_rows,failed_colsandn_unscored, which the app shows as a warning above the synergy panel. Optional keyword-onlyasymmetry_hor/asymmetry_verfor 5p drugs.
Plotting (synfit.plotting):
zip_heatmap(...)— callszip_delta(), thenmatrix_heatmap()withRdBucentred at 0 (same diverging scale as the Bliss deviation heatmap: negative δ toward red, positive toward blue).